The Philadelphia Phillies have had their fair share of trade talks over the years, often walking the fine line between pushing for contention and safeguarding their future. As the offseason heats up, the front office is undoubtedly reflecting on past moves—or the lack thereof. Here are two key players the Phillies are grateful for not dealing away and one regrettable pursuit that has left the organization reconsidering their strategy.
Grateful Hold No. 1: Alec Bohm – The Cornerstone Infielder
Alec Bohm’s name has surfaced in trade rumors multiple times during his tenure in Philadelphia. However, the Phillies’ decision to hold onto the young infielder is proving to be a masterstroke. Bohm, known for his steady bat and improving defense, has evolved into a key contributor in the Phillies’ lineup.
In 2024, Bohm notched a career-high in RBIs and provided clutch performances during the postseason. His ability to hit for contact and power while offering versatility at both corner infield spots has made him indispensable. For a team often linked to high-profile third basemen in trade talks, Bohm’s development has validated the Phillies’ patience. Letting him go could have created a long-term void at a position critical to their future success.
Grateful Hold No. 2: Bryson Stott – The All-Around Spark Plug
Bryson Stott, another homegrown talent, was once rumored to be included in potential blockbuster trades. Fast forward to now, and Stott has cemented himself as the heart of the Phillies’ infield. His defensive prowess at second base and occasional starts at shortstop give the Phillies incredible flexibility.
Offensively, Stott has become the quintessential leadoff hitter, combining speed, on-base ability, and an uncanny knack for coming through in big moments. His postseason heroics in recent years have only reinforced his value. Trading Stott would have left a gaping hole in the Phillies’ lineup and robbed them of a player who embodies their gritty, never-say-die identity.
Regret: The Shocking Pursuit of Juan Soto
While the Phillies avoided some disastrous deals, their aggressive pursuit of superstar outfielder Juan Soto during the 2024 trade deadline has left lingering regret. Soto, an MVP-caliber talent, was seen as the missing piece for a championship run. The Phillies reportedly dangled top prospects and young talent, including rising pitcher Andrew Painter and slugger Johan Rojas.
Ultimately, the deal fell through as the asking price grew too steep. While Soto did help his acquiring team make a deep playoff run, the Phillies now feel fortunate not to have emptied their farm system. However, the emotional toll of nearly losing Painter—a pitcher many compare to Hall of Famer Roy Halladay—continues to resonate within the organization.
Adding to the drama, the Phillies shockingly doubled back on their pursuit of Soto this offseason. The move left fans and analysts scratching their heads, as the financial commitment to Soto could jeopardize their ability to extend homegrown stars like Stott and Bohm. The mixed messaging around their strategy has reignited debates about whether the team’s win-now mentality aligns with long-term sustainability.
Looking Ahead
As the Phillies continue to balance their desire for immediate success with a focus on sustainable growth, the lessons of past decisions loom large. Bohm and Stott represent the rewards of patience and belief in young talent, while the Soto saga serves as a cautionary tale of chasing shiny objects at the expense of a solid foundation.
With Spring Training just around the corner, the Phillies can be grateful for the talent they’ve retained—and hopeful that their next big move is a step in the right direction.
Leave a Reply