The Milwaukee Brewers face an interesting dilemma with star shortstop nearing a potential $200 million contract extension., who has become an integral part of the team’s success since joining the Brewers in 2021, is entering the final season of his contract in 2024, and the conversation surrounding his future with the team has heated up. While the Brewers are eager to keep his powerful bat and leadership in the clubhouse, a long-term extension in the range of $200 million raises important questions about’ future role, particularly his position on the field.
‘ Impact on the Brewers
Since arriving from the Tampa Bay Rays, has been a cornerstone of Milwaukee’s infield and a fan favorite. His combination of power and defense has made him one of the top shortstops in the league. In 2023, Adames hit 24 home runs and drove in 86 RBIs, providing the Brewers with a reliable source of offense. Additionally, his energy and leadership have helped to set the tone for the team, making him a key figure in the Brewers’ recent playoff appearances.
However, despite his contributions, the Brewers have to carefully consider the long-term financial and roster implications of such a significant contract. With a number of talented young players in the system and an evolving league where shortstops are expected to have greater range and defensive flexibility, the Brewers may explore the possibility of a position change for Adames if they commit to keeping him around for the next decade.
Why a Position Change Could Be Considered
1. **Defensive Performance Decline**: Although Adames has been a solid defensive shortstop for most of his career, advanced metrics suggest his range and defensive capabilities may be declining as he enters his late 20s. Defensive statistics like Outs Above Average (OAA) and Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) have shown a slight dip in his performance. This could become a concern if the Brewers are planning to sign him to a contract that could keep him in Milwaukee well into his 30s. As players age, their defensive skills, particularly at demanding positions like shortstop, tend to decline.
2. **Emerging Talent in the Brewers’ Farm System**: The Brewers have a number of talented infielders coming through their minor league system, including Brice Turang and Jefferson Quero. Turang, who made his MLB debut in 2023, is a natural shortstop with elite defensive tools. Moving Adames to another position, such as third base or second base, could open up opportunities for these younger players to take over at shortstop while allowing Adames to extend his career without the wear and tear of playing the most demanding defensive position.
3. **Comparisons to Other High-Paid Infielders**: Around the league, several high-profile shortstops have made position changes after securing large contracts. For example, Manny Machado, originally a shortstop, transitioned to third base after signing his $300 million deal with the San Diego Padres. Likewise, Corey Seager and Marcus Semien have shifted positions as they aged or joined new teams. If Adames were to sign a $200 million deal, the Brewers could explore a similar path, positioning him where his bat remains impactful but his defensive responsibilities are reduced.
4. **Contract Length and Durability**: A contract approaching $200 million would likely keep Adames in Milwaukee for six to eight years or longer. This kind of commitment necessitates forward thinking about his role as he ages. By moving him off shortstop, the Brewers could potentially prolong his effectiveness as a hitter and reduce the risk of injuries. Transitioning him to a corner infield position would lessen the physical demands, allowing Adames to focus on maintaining his offensive production, which is where much of his value lies.
### Where Would Adames Fit Best?
If a position change becomes necessary, the most logical fit for Adames would be third base. He has the arm strength required for the position, and his power bat aligns with the expectations for a third baseman. The Brewers currently have Brian Anderson and Andruw Monasterio as options at third, but neither has locked down the position long-term. Adames could make a smooth transition to third base, providing the Brewers with both a defensive upgrade and a powerful offensive presence.
Another option could be second base, where the Brewers might need more offense. Moving to second would reduce the strain on Adames’ body compared to shortstop, and it could allow Milwaukee to explore different combinations in their infield with younger players like Turang taking over at shortstop.
Balancing Financial and Roster Decisions
Ultimately, the Brewers face a balancing act. Signing Willy Adames to a $200 million contract extension would send a strong message that the team is committed to competing for championships and retaining its key players. However, it also presents significant challenges, especially given the Brewers’ small-market status and payroll constraints. A large contract could limit their ability to make other moves in free agency or to extend other core players like Corbin Burnes or Brandon Woodruff.
To justify such a large investment, the Brewers may need to get creative with their roster construction. Adames’ long-term value could be maximized by a position change that allows the team to maintain flexibility and give younger, more defensively gifted players a chance to shine at shortstop.
Conclusion
Willy Adames is a crucial part of the Brewers’ present and could be a key figure in their future. However, if Milwaukee decides to offer him a contract approaching $200 million, it may come with a position change to extend his value to the team. With young talent emerging and defensive metrics raising concerns, the Brewers will need to weigh the benefits of Adames’ bat and leadership against the long-term sustainability of keeping him at shortstop. As the offseason unfolds, this decision could be one of the most pivotal in shaping the future of the Milwaukee Brewers.
Leave a Reply